
August 26, 2005
Volume 49, Issue 32
Statewide Poll Shows Overwhelming Support for
Non-Economic Damage Cap
Impact of High Court decision ripples across state
A recent editorial in the Wall Street Journal referred to Wisconsin as "Alabama North," WHA Senior Vice President Eric Borgerding told reporters attending a news conference sponsored by the Wisconsin Hospital Association and the Wisconsin Medical Society at the State Capitol on August 25.
"That is a not-so-subtle reference to the fact that Wisconsin has become a much more litigation-friendly environment following the Supreme Court decision to eliminate caps on non-economic damages," Borgerding chided.
"On the other hand, we have also seen a tremendous amount of activity in the six weeks since the decision. The speaker’s Task Force was created, and legislators on both sides of the aisle are working diligently to craft a solution to what they know is a problem on the horizon," Borgerding said. "We commend all of these rapid responses. We are anxious to work with the Legislature and the Governor not only to pass a bill, but to enact a law that will address this situation."
Brad Cole, mayor of Carbondale, Illinois, described himself as "just a country boy from Southern Illinois," but he brought a stunning and sobering message to reporters, legislative staffers, and trial attorneys gathered at the news conference in Madison.
Mayor Cole related a personal and painful story of how the lack of access to neurologists in the Town of Carbondale may have contributed to the death of his friend after she suffered severe head trauma. It was four hours after her fall down a flight of stairs before she was able to see a neurosurgeon because she had to be transported by helicopter to St. Louis, Missouri, 100 miles away.
"Part of this story began months before my friend’s fall. It began in May 2004 when our region’s only two neurosurgeons stopped seeing patients and closed their successful practices to move out of Illinois. They moved because of the unfriendly environment that had been created," Cole related.
When the Illinois General Assembly was unwilling to address some type of substantive reform, Mayor Cole took matters into his own hands. He proposed a local city ordinance that placed a cap on non-economic damages and also placed a venue restriction on where suits could be filed.
Those actions catapulted the issue to a statewide level "like no one ever imagined," he said. Medical liability became the central and deciding factor in a statewide Supreme Court justice election and it forced the state legislature to finally address this issue.
"And I am pleased to say at this moment, the Governor of Illinois is signing into law liability reforms and other caps to help protect our physicians, but especially to protect the citizens of my community," Cole said.
He added, "No one knows what type of similar situations will arise here in Wisconsin if the system is allowed to spiral down out of control in the absence of a cap and necessary physician protections."
"I encourage the Wisconsin general assembly and the people of Wisconsin to come before this measure and return it to law to protect your friends, family and neighbors," Cole concluded.
Later in the news conference, Sandy Anderson, president of St. Clare’s Hospital in Baraboo, seized the opportunity to respond to a question from a reporter who asked if the speakers have "seen the ball rolling on this issue?"
Anderson responded, "I can tell you I have interviewed two orthopedic surgeons in the past two weeks and the first words that came out of their mouths, were, ‘what is going to happen to our malpractice rates?’ And the answer I had to give them was, ‘I don’t know…I really don’t know’."
Susan Turney, MD, CEO/EVP of the Wisconsin Medical Society said, "If family medicine doctors in small communities no longer deliver babies because their liability insurance rates are going off the charts, where will that leave our patients?"
Confirming Turney’s comment, Anderson said unlike larger communities, almost all family medicine doctors in rural areas deliver babies. Anderson, who came to Wisconsin from Ohio, one of AMA’s 20 medical liability crisis states, said liability insurance rates drove family medicine doctors to stop delivering babies. Fortunately, she said the community was able to retain one obstetrician, who was on call "365 days a year."
"Unfortunately, on the day I was to deliver our girls, he happened to be out on his farm and it was difficult for him to get in. There was a chance I was going to have to be transported one hour away. I thought that was appalling," she said.
"It took Ohio only two years to raise the liability rates to the point where family practitioners could no longer afford to deliver babies. We don’t want to see that happen here," Anderson cautioned.
Wisconsin Overwhelmingly Supports Medical Malpractice CapThe following is a news release that was issued by WHA to the statewide press on August 25, 2005.
MADISON (August 25, 2005)—— Concerns that health care costs will rise is just one reason why the public supports reinstating a cap on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. Just six weeks ago, the Wisconsin Supreme Court struck down the cap, but according to a statewide poll released today by the Wisconsin Hospital Association and Wisconsin Medical Society, public support is already overwhelmingly in favor of putting an effective cap back in place.
More than 75 percent of Wisconsin residents who were asked said they would favor a new law to reinstate a limit on medical malpractice damage awards that are related to pain and suffering. Support is so strong, in fact, that it carries to the voting booth as 68 percent of the respondents said they would be more likely to vote for a candidate for the state legislature who supported a cap. That sentiment is derived from a bi-partisan sampling of 500 Wisconsin voters, including some who said they had filed a personal injury lawsuit in the past.
In addition to rising health care costs, respondents said they fear that without a cap, a medical liability crisis will force doctors to stop practicing in or leave Wisconsin. There was also a fear that access to obstetrical care and life-saving services, such as brain surgery, will be limited.
Experiences in other states prove these concerns are very real. Skyrocketing medical liability premiums have caused physicians to stop practicing in states without caps, such as Oregon, Washington and Illinois, to name just a few. Trauma units have closed in southern Illinois, and one-third of the obstetricians in Oregon have stopped delivering babies in that state only three years after losing their cap on non-economic damages.
WHA Senior Vice President Eric Borgerding said Wisconsin can’t afford to take a "wait and see what happens" position.
"We had an enviable medical malpractice environment before the Supreme Court struck down the caps because it protected injured patients while ensuring that all patients could access medical care," Borgerding said. "The more the public learns about the consequences the high court’s action will have on their access to health care when they need it, the more supportive they are of restoring the cap."
Gene Ulm, a partner in Public Opinion Strategies, the polling group that conducted the study for WHA and the Society, agreed with Borgerding. Ulm said the results clearly show that residents here don’t want to repeat other state’s mistakes.
"Support was strong, 66 percent, even before respondents were asked to react to factual statements that described how access to health care changed in states without caps," Ulm explained. "After they heard that high medical liability premiums cause physicians to leave, trauma centers to close, and women to show up to deliver babies without having any prenatal care because there was not an obstetrician in their community, the public support for reinstating the cap goes through the roof."
When malpractice insurance rates soar, it leaves rural and inner cities areas particularly vulnerable to physician shortages. Sandy Anderson, president of St. Clare Hospital in Baraboo, said recruiting and retaining physicians is an on-going challenge. One made even more difficult now.
"Physicians are in demand in all areas of the country," said Anderson. "Rural hospitals in Wisconsin are not only competing with larger cities for doctors, but with other states."
"The difficulty we have is getting physicians to come to a rural area to practice," Anderson continued. "That difficulty is compounded if they won’t even consider coming to Wisconsin."
Borgerding emphasized that 89 percent of those asked said the Governor and Legislature should consider this issue a "priority."
"Clearly, state legislators should know that their constituents are concerned about the future of health care in Wisconsin, and they are willing to vote for those candidates who support making health care accessible to all citizens in our state," he concluded.
President’s ColumnThis coming Tuesday, August 30, the organizational meeting of the Speaker’s Task Force on Medical Malpractice Reform will occur in Madison. The 10-member group—five lawmakers and five public members—is charged with developing legislation to preserve Wisconsin’s favorable (until last month’s Supreme Court decision) medical liability climate. And the central theme that will become a mantra during Task Force discussions is the need to reinstate a statutory cap on non-economic damages.
As revealed this week at a State Capitol press conference, public support for caps on non-economic damage awards is extremely strong with 75 percent of survey respondents favoring caps and 18 percent opposing award limits. And one-half of respondents indicated strongly favorable support for monetary limits.
A further review of survey results shows that the public understands the consequences of a capless world and the urgency of restoring a stable medical malpractice environment. Survey respondents consider non-economic damage caps to be a high priority for address by Governor Doyle and the Wisconsin Legislature. Specifically, 89 percent identify the issue as a priority…and 68 percent of survey respondents say that they will be more likely to vote for candidates in the future who support strict limits on non-economic damage awards.
The political climate for undoing the damage created by the Wisconsin Supreme Court in July is present. The legislative will for addressing the issue this fall is strong. Statewide editorial support, focusing on potential future access problems and health care cost concerns, is also evident. There are but two significant questions: Where will Governor Doyle be on the issue? And how will the Wisconsin Supreme Court eventually rule on a "legislative fix"? The answers to those questions, of course, will ultimately determine whether a legislative fix—as opposed to a constitutional amendment—will be the vehicle for restoring award caps.
Wisconsin’s historically favorable medical malpractice environment is not due solely to caps on non-economic damages. The presence of the Patient Compensation Fund, which acts as a re-insurer for large claims; the presence of well regarded community-focused hospitals and physician groups; and the comparatively high quality health care provided by Wisconsin’s providers, all contributed to what was a blending of favorable factors that made Wisconsin almost unique among the states. But the fact is, one of those important ingredients is now absent and its restoration must be our most significant, short-term advocacy priority.
Steve Brenton
President
While the temperature outside may be cooling off as the end of summer approaches, the thermometer measuring contributions to the Wisconsin Hospitals PAC, Conduit and AHA PAC continues to climb. Contributions have reached nearly $143,000, which accounts for 82 percent of the goal to raise $175,000 in this calendar year.
"While we are getting closer to reaching the goal, it is even more imperative that we reach that goal and even exceed that goal if we can. We must be able to support our friends in their re-election campaigns and work to elect new representatives who understand the value of hospitals to their communities, while working to defeat those who don’t," according to WHA’s Jodi Bloch, vice president, government affairs.
Special thanks goes out to the following individuals who have contributed to the 2005 Campaign.
Contributions ranging from $1 - $249
Kowalkowski, Carolyn St. Joseph’s Hospital
Baalrud, Laura St. Joseph’s Hospital
Korff, Sarah St. Nicholas Hospital
McKay, Jean Sacred Heart Hospital
Melby, Shirley Tri-County Memorial Hospital
Olszewski, Kathleen Saint Michael’s Hospital
Skulan-Balmer, Anna Sacred Heart Hospital
Tandberg, Christine Sacred Heart Hospital
Axelsen, Kathern Sacred Heart Hospital
Anderson, Mark Sacred Heart Hospital
Margan, Rob Wisconsin Hospital Association
Carlson, Carol Sacred Heart Hospital
Gullicksrud, Lynn Sacred Heart Hospital
Hon, Ronald Sacred Heart Hospital
Hundt, Pamela Sacred Heart Hospital
Konopacky, Kathy Saint Michael’s Hospital
Lien, Kristine Sacred Heart Hospital
Mickelson, Ronald St. Clare Hospital & Health Services
Ose, Peggy Riverview Hospital Association
Pielhop, Judy Sacred Heart Hospital
Piper, Barbara Sacred Heart Hospital
Reinke, Kathy Shawano Medical Center
Smalley, Scott St. Joseph’s Hospital
Spanos, Chris Meriter Hospital
Wulff, Gary St. Joseph’s Hospital
Anderson, Sherry St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Krause, Elaine St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Seldal, Kent Memorial Medical Center
Barkovich, Catherine Sacred Heart Hospital
Gahagan, Marsha St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Marcouiller, Don Memorial Medical Center
Carlson, Kathleen Memorial Medical Center
Monien, Yvonne Saint Michael’s Hospital
Schrage, Karen St. Joseph’s Hospital
Lucas, Ann Wisconsin Hospital Association
Aittama, Craig Saint Michael’s Hospital
Anich, Matthew Memorial Medical Center
Barry, Barbara Memorial Medical Center
Betthauser, Sue Mile Bluff Medical Center
Brunner, Pam Sacred Heart Hospital
Caven, Michael Memorial Medical Center
Cohen, Joan Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Dittrich, Peggy Memorial Health Center
Drengler, Kathryn Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Dwyer, Amy Sacred Heart Hospital
Gamroth, Charlotte Tri-County Memorial Hospital
Giedd, Jan St. Joseph’s Hospital
Lorenz, Bruce Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Maurer, Mary Holy Family Memorial Medical Center
Meicher, John St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Meixelsperger, Jeffrey St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Meyer, Markie Community Memorial Hospital
Nezworski, Joseph Sacred Heart Hospital
Nicolaus, David Flambeau Hospital
O’Brien, Susan St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Olson, Keri St. Clare Hospital & Health Services
Ott, Virginia St. Joseph’s Hospital
Pengra, Mary Sacred Heart Hospital
Pittsley, Kim Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Polenz, Scott Sacred Heart Hospital
Posthuma, Diane Waupun Memorial Hospital
Richbourg, Mary Sacred Heart Hospital
Santini, Kathy Memorial Medical Center
Schmelzle, Barbara Sacred Heart Hospital
Skifton, Russell Saint Michael’s Hospital
Smith, Ellen St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Sullivan, Anne Memorial Medical Center
Voigt, Yolanda Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Vorwald, Virginia St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Aminpour, Ali Sacred Heart Hospital
Clark, Dennis St. Joseph’s Hospital
Craft, Carolyn St. Joseph’s Hospital
Dalebroux, Steve St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Baetke, Jan Aurora Medical Center - Manitowoc
Baker, David Saint Michael’s Hospital
Beckler, Rick Sacred Heart Hospital
Beers, William St. Clare Hospital & Health Services
Benn, Cheryl Sacred Heart Hospital
Benusa, Kris Tri-County Memorial Hospital
Bessen, Paulette Saint Michael’s Hospital
Boyce, Sherry Saint Michael’s Hospital
Bradford, Deborah Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Burmeister, Kerry Columbia St. Mary’s-Milwaukee
Buss, Diane St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Christensen, Leslie St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Clark, Julie Ann St. Joseph’s Hospital
Coats, Robert Meriter Hospital
DeMars, Nancy Sacred Heart Hospital
Fedie, Robin St. Joseph’s Hospital
Folstad, John Sacred Heart Hospital
Gantner, Sue Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Gaskell, Rose Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Goffinet, Jo St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Haeberle, Judith ProHealth Care
Hartman, Katherine St. Joseph’s Hospital
Hassemer, Robert Sacred Heart Hospital
Heider, Lisa Community Memorial Hospital
Hemes, Lisa St. Elizabeth Hospital
Hook, James St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Huemmer, Paul St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Jahnke, John Waukesha Memorial Hospital
Jensema, Christine St. Nicholas Hospital
Johnson, Kimberly Sacred Heart Hospital
Jones, Mary Meriter Hospital
King, Steve Saint Michael’s Hospital
LaBarge, Margie Saint Michael’s Hospital
LuCore, Michael Sacred Heart Hospital
LuCore, Patricia Sacred Heart Hospital
Maersch, Nancy Meriter Hospital
Marnell, John Hudson Hospital
Marten, Donna Sacred Heart Hospital
Mason, Robert Sacred Heart Hospital
Mathews, Larry St. Vincent Hospital
May, Carol Mercy Health System
McKenzie, Paula St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Niekamp, Robert Saint Michael’s Hospital
Padilla, Gilbert Sacred Heart Hospital
Pahl, Joan Meriter Hospital
Peot, Tracy Bellin Memorial Hospital
Peskie, Walt Flambeau Hospital
Pfeifer, Patricia Saint Michael’s Hospital
Possin, Charles Meriter Hospital
Ries, John St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Rothenbuehler, Gary St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Schultz, Rebecca Sacred Heart Hospital
Schwoegler, Mary St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Shipman, Elisa Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Shoup, Judy St. Michael Hospital
Shulfer, Susan Saint Michael’s Hospital
Sparks, Steven St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Sprengeler, John Sacred Heart Hospital
Stanton, Gary Memorial Health Center
Stubbs, Pat Mile Bluff Medical Center
Studer, Vince Shawano Medical Center
Swanson, Bert St. Joseph’s Hospital
Thorsness, Tom Sacred Heart Hospital
VanDeVoort, John Sacred Heart Hospital
Watts, Susan St. Vincent Hospital
Bundner, Mark Meriter Hospital
Chandler, Susan Meriter Hospital
Deich, Faye Sacred Heart Hospital
Eckman, Theresa St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Elsen, Mary Pat St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Facey, Alice St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Groth, Kathy Meriter Retirement Services
Jacobsen, Joan Meriter Hospital
Jelle, Laura St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Marggi, Michele St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Roethle, Linda Bellin Psychiatric Center
Ruehl, Teena Wisconsin Hospital Association
Schaetzl, Ron St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Skiles, Anna Meriter Hospital
Walker, Troy St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Weden, Mary Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Werner, Kathleen Meriter Hospital
Whiteaker, Les Memorial Medical Center
Albers, Kirstin Meriter Hospital
Anderson, Frances Meriter Retirement Services
Anderson, Susan Beloit Memorial Hospital
Baer, James Shawano Medical Center
Beck, James All Saints Healthcare
Beglinger, Joan St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Benson, Karen L St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Boland, Susan All Saints Healthcare
Brenny, Terrence Stoughton Hospital Association
Carr Lee, Mary Meriter Hospital
Coller, James St. Mary’s Hospital Medical Center
Dassenko, Dennis University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
DesJarlais, Robert Aurora Medical Center - Manitowoc
Dittmar, Clarence Community Memorial Hospital
Driggers, Steve Holy Family Memorial Medical Center
Dwyer, Maxine St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Fenske, William Agnesian HealthCare
Flanagan, Tracy Sacred Heart Hospital
Forbush, Marilyn St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Fry, Robert Bellin Memorial Hospital
Gilles-Khouri, Lucy St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Helin, Shelby St. Joseph’s Hospital
Herbert, William Meriter Hospital
Hoege, Beverly Reedsburg Area Medical Center
Jablonske, William St. Joseph’s Hospital
Kramper, Edward Wisconsin Hospital Association
Lemke, Debra Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Lensen, Kathie St. Nicholas Hospital
Macken, Thomas Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Martin, Julie Meriter Hospital
McAvoy, Michael All Saints Healthcare
McCloskey, Lynne Saint Michael’s Hospital
Meyer, Loren All Saints Healthcare
Mohr, Carol Sacred Heart Hospital
Mosack, Kathleen Sacred Heart Hospital
Mueller, Bonita St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Mugan, James Agnesian HealthCare
Nicklaus, Ronald Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Nohelty, Peter Sacred Heart Hospital
Overholt, Peter Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Pangborn, Janet St. Michael Hospital
Pechan, Marlene St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Peiffer, Susan Sacred Heart Hospital
Piehl, Steven Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Pieters, Donald St. Nicholas Hospital
Pinekenstein, Barbara Meriter Hospital
Post, A Charles Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Prince, Nancy Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Riegler, John Aurora Health Care
Rocole, Theresa All Saints Healthcare
Rothfuss, James Meriter Hospital
Rounds, Thomas St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Rubenzer, Deanne St. Joseph’s Hospital
Schmidt, Kari Aurora Health Care
Schultz, Rhea Meriter Hospital
Schulz, Janet Oconomowoc Memorial Hospital
Sio, Tim Meriter Hospital
Stenson, Jill Agnesian HealthCare
Sutton, Mary St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Thompson, Mark Aurora Health Care
Thundercloud, Debbie Bellin Memorial Hospital
Utech, Laura Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Van Winkle, Gregory Community Memorial Hospital
Ballentine, Anne Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Callies, Julie WHA Information Center
Boylan, Michelle Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Burgener, Jean Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Burgett, Lyle Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Casanova, James Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Clark, Mary Ann Cumberland Memorial Hospital
Danner, Forrest Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Dietrich, Dean Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Dietsche, James Bellin Memorial Hospital
Ellis, Nancy Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Erickson, Robert Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Gengler, Tim Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Gifford, Bridget WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Hessert, Peter Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Klauck, James Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Maloney, Barbara Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
McBrearty, Mary Jo St. Nicholas Hospital
Nevers, Rick Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Petersen, Mary Beth Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Postler-Slattery, Diane Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Raaum, Karl Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Roberts, Mary Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Scherff, Pam Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Schroeder-Jaeger, Keri Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Sczygelski, Sidney Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Svetlik, Joe Reedsburg Area Medical Center
Yunk, Dennis Agnesian HealthCare
Bellin, Carolyn Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Bernklau, Robert Memorial Health Center
Burger, Kristy Moundview Memorial Hospital/Clinics
Connell, Marilyn Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Franson, Patricia Meriter Hospital
Hemes, Jim St. Elizabeth Hospital
Hinner, William Saint Michael’s Hospital
Hisgen, William Meriter Hospital
Hofer, John Bay Area Medical Center
Leonard, Mary Kay St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Lockhart, MD, Jack Gundersen Lutheran Medical Center
Mulder, Doris Beloit Memorial Hospital
Onsager, Sandra St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Peterson, Douglas Chippewa Valley Hospital/Oakview Care
Schill, Jane Saint Michael’s Hospital
Schriner, Janet Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Strombom, Peter Meriter Hospital
Cote, Sean WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Contributions ranging from $250 - $499
Schumacher, Elizabeth Meriter Hospital
Ambrosius, Mark St. Luke’s Medical Center
Arnett, E. Stuart Aurora Health Care-South Region
Baker, Chris St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Bestor, William Community Memorial Hospital
Bezucha, Gary Boscobel Area Health Care
Biros, Marilyn SSM Health Care-Wisconsin
Blanchard, Michael Saint Joseph’s Hospital
Blask, Daniel ProHealth Care
Buerstatte, Gary Waukesha Memorial Hospital
Bukowski, Cathy Our Lady of Victory Hospital
Dallman, Michael University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Dreher, Charles Columbia St. Mary’s-Milwaukee
Ellis, Sandra Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Erickson, William Sacred Heart-St. Mary’s Hospitals
Fischer, Kay Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Fish, Linda Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Greene, Roxanne Our Lady of Victory Hospital
Grimstad, Vicki Aurora Health Care
Hamilton, Mark University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Hammer, Michael Good Samaritan Health Center of Merrill
Hanson-Melzer, Rita St. Joseph’s Regional Medical Center
Harding, Edward Columbus Community Hospital
Heifetz, Michael SSM Health Care-Wisconsin
Hendricks, Richard St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Hill, Cheryl Columbia St. Mary’s Ozaukee Campus
Hilt, Monica Sacred Heart-St. Mary’s Hospitals
Hinton, George Aurora Sinai Medical Center
Hoff, Linda Meriter Hospital
Huettl, Patty Sacred Heart Hospital
Hyland, Carol Agnesian HealthCare
Jablonski, James Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Jaeger, Lee Aurora Health Care
Jensen, Russell St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Johnson, Curtis Tri-County Memorial Hospital
Krauklis, Gene Aurora Health Care-South Region
Kuiper, Laurie Aurora Health Care
Lange, MD, George M. Wisconsin Medical Society
Mattes, Dan Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
McCutcheon, Norma Wisconsin Heart Hospital, The
Miller, Barbara St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Mlynarek, Robert Oconomowoc Memorial Hospital
Neidenbach, Joseph St. Vincent Hospital
Neikirk, Jon Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Nelson, Nanine ProHealth Care
Nick, Mary Meriter Hospital
Norton, Andrew Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Nunn, Jake St. Luke’s Medical Center
Olkowski, Leland Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Paul, Mary Kay Columbia St. Mary’s
Penczykowski, James St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Peterson, Kimberly Bellin Memorial Hospital
Rouzer, Cindy Spooner Health System
Sanicola, Suzanne Columbia St. Mary’s-Columbia
Siebecker, William Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Spieckerman, Jill Sacred Heart-St. Mary’s Hospitals
Steevens, Alan St. Clare Hospital & Health Services
Tait, Karen Howard Young Medical Center
Weisman, Steven Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Werner, Cinda Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Miloszewicz, Angela Wisconsin Hospital Association
Bayer, Tom St. Vincent Hospital
Brandel, Patrick Holy Family Memorial Medical Center
Ayers, Mandy Wisconsin Hospital Association
Schumann, Shannon WHA Information Center
Carlson, Dan Bay Area Medical Center
Christianson, Roger St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Decker, Michael Divine Savior Healthcare
Friese, Carolyn St. Vincent Hospital
Hymans, Daniel Memorial Medical Center
Kellar, Richard West Allis Memorial Hospital
Kuzel, Russel Aurora Health Care
Mantei, Mary Jo Bay Area Medical Center
McGee, Fred Meriter Hospital
Meyer, Miles Meriter Hospital
Myers, Raymond St. Joseph’s Hospital
Neet, Bradley Saint Michael’s Hospital
Oberholtzer, Curt Bay Area Medical Center
Priest, MD, Geoffrey Meriter Hospital
Rickelman, Debbie WHA Information Center
Ronstrom, Stephen Sacred Heart Hospital
Simuncak, Sandra Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Skaden, John Saint Joseph’s Hospital
Van Court, Bernie Bay Area Medical Center
Needham, Jean Holy Family Hospital
Pandl, Therese Columbia St. Mary’s-Milwaukee
White, Michelle WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Barnett, Jane University Health Care, Inc.
Bultema, Janice University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Byrne, Frank St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Devermann, Robert Aurora Medical Center of Oshkosh
Grundstrom, David Flambeau Hospital
Contributions ranging from $500 - $999
Anderson, Sandy St. Clare Hospital and Health Services
Buck, Catherine Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Christensen, Cinthia Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Duncan, Larry Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Dykehouse, Rodney Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Entwistle, David University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Flowers, Patty Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Forman, Elizabeth Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Getto, Carl University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Goodenow, John Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Grady, Glen Memorial Medical Center
Groepper, Ron St. Joseph’s Regional Medical Center
Gutzeit, Michael Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Heisler, John SSM Health Care-Wisconsin
Johnson, Charles St. Marys Hospital Medical Center
Jones, Michael Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Kerwin, George Bellin Memorial Hospital
Ketterhagen, James Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Kinsella, Connie University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Korom, Nancy Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Kosanovich, John Watertown Memorial Hospital
Martin, Jeff Saint Michael’s Hospital
Modjeska, Alicia St. Michael Hospital
Niemer, Margaret Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
O’Connell, Blaine Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Potter, Terri Meriter Hospital
Range, Richard Baldwin Area Medical Center
Reynolds, Sheila Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Richards, Theresa Saint Joseph’s Hospital
Robertstad, John Oconomowoc Memorial Hospital
Runge, Charles Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
Schafer, Michael Spooner Health System
Schmidt, Michael Saint Joseph’s Hospital
Schroeder, Patricia Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Standridge, Debra St. Francis Hospital
Steiner, Garith Vernon Memorial Healthcare
Teigen, Bobbe Aurora Medical Center - Manitowoc
Thompson, Scott Aurora Health Care
Frank, Jennifer WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Grasmick, Mary Kay Wisconsin Hospital Association
Brasseaux, Mary St. Nicholas Hospital
Richardson, Dana Wisconsin Hospital Association
Buser, Kenneth All Saints Healthcare
Riddle, Roberta Wisconsin Hospital Association
Eichman, Cynthia Our Lady of Victory Hospital
Falvey, Patrick Aurora Health Care
Fish, David St. Joseph’s Hospital
Karuschak, Michael Amery Regional Medical Center
Kief, Brian Howard Young Medical Center
McCausland, Maureen University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Meyer, Daniel Aurora Sheboygan Mem. Medical Ctr.
Morgan, Dwight Aurora Health Care
Wick, Timothy Burnett Medical Center
Reardon, John Memorial Medical Center
Contributions ranging from $1000 - $1999
Anderson, Loren Aurora Health Care-South Region
Banks, P. Gregory Aurora Health Care - Kettle Moraine
Birkenstock, Timothy Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Bolz, Terry University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Bonk, Daniel Aurora Sheboygan Mem. Medical Ctr.
Brideau, Leo Columbia St. Mary’s-Columbia Campus
Britton, Gregory Beloit Memorial Hospital
Buettner, Susan Aurora Health Care
Desien, Nicholas Ministry Health Care
Dunigan, Thomas Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Ela, Susan Aurora Health Care
Fale, Robert Agnesian HealthCare
Gazzana, Thomas Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Huxley, Eliot Aurora Health Care
Johnson, George Reedsburg Area Medical Center
Kaufman, Nancy Aurora Health Care
Koehler, Thomas Aurora BayCare Medical Center
Milakovich, Paul Aurora Health Care
Munson, Kenneth Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Olson, Edward Waukesha Memorial Hospital
Rudolph, Colin Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Shabino, Charles Aspirus Wausau Hospital
Smith, Linda Aurora BayCare Medical Center
Steinman, John Aurora Health Care
Tapper, Joy Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Titus, Rexford ProHealth Care
Turkal, Nick Aurora Health Care
Walsh, Lorelle Aurora Health Care
Bazan, Bill Wisconsin Hospital Association
Bloch, Jodi Wisconsin Hospital Association
Braddock, Jonathan WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Cutler, Dave WHA Financial Solutions, Inc.
Dell Uomo, Paul Covenant Healthcare System, Inc.
Quinn, George Wisconsin Hospital Association
Kachelski, Joe WHA Information Center
Westrick, Paul Columbia St. Mary’s-Milwaukee Campus
Leitch, Laura Wisconsin Hospital Association
Stanford, Matthew Wisconsin Hospital Association
Olson, David Bay Area Medical Center
Nannis, Paul Aurora Health Care
Warmuth, Judith Wisconsin Hospital Association
Eiler, Gary University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Vice, Jon Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Starmann-Harrison, Mary SSM Health Care-Wisconsin
Wolf, Edward Lakeview Medical Center
Contributions $2000 and above
Sollenberger, Donna University of Wisconsin Hospital/Clinics
Brenton, Mary E. Wisconsin Hospital Association
Brenton, Stephen Wisconsin Hospital Association
Borgerding, Eric Wisconsin Hospital Association
Size, Tim Rural Wisconsin Health Cooperative
Howe, Edwin Aurora Health Care
Saint Joseph’s Hospital/Ministry Health Care Host Congressman GreenStopping along the way for refreshment at the Starbucks in the lobby, Congressman Mark Green (R-8th) began his visit at Saint Joseph’s Hospital/Ministry Health Care by greeting hospital administration and staff before taking a quick walking tour of the facility.
During the tour, Congressman Green discussed the issue of community benefits with Ann Boson, Foundation manager, and Mike Blanchard, vice president of administrative services, both of whom shared facts about the over $5 million in charitable care provided to over 1,220 individuals. In addition, they mentioned the $396,638 in donations that Saint Joseph’s Hospital/Ministry Health Fund provides to support community programs and services. Both also cited new efforts to reduce costs and length of stay while working with businesses to improve the health of their employees through improved information and referral.
In turning to the Supreme Court’s recent medical malpractice ruling, Michael Schmidt, President, made sure to thank Green for authoring the 1995 legislation that established the caps on non-economic damages. Schmidt indicated he is looking forward to the work of the Medical Malpractice Reform Task Force, recently created by Assembly Speaker John Gard (R-Peshtigo), that will review legislative options for reform. Congressman Green communicated his concern over the issue as well as the future for health care in the state. Green further indicated health care was one of his top priorities.
Karla Ashenhurst, Government Affairs Director for Ministry Health Care, encouraged Congressman Green to hold health care listening sessions at Saint Joseph’s or another Ministry site and asked him to encourage Representative Gielow to bring the Speaker’s Task Force on Medical Malpractice reform to Saint Joseph’s for a hands-on assessment of the crisis at hand. President Schmidt concluded with an offer to provide staff experts with administrative or clinical information, as hospitals work together to make Wisconsin a state that will continue to draw some of the finest physicians in the nation.
We’d love to showcase your hospital in our Grassroots Spotlight. Let us know your hospital’s grassroots activities by contacting Jenny Boese at 608-268-1816 or
jboese@wha.org.Top
Registration Materials Available for 2005 Wisconsin Quality & Safety Forum
Scheduled for October 17-18 in Appleton
The full education agenda and registration materials for the 2005 Wisconsin Quality & Safety Forum are included in this week’s packet and are available on-line at www.wha.org.
Health care quality managers, risk managers, CEOs/administrators, clinician managers, physicians, nurses, pharmacists, patient care services staff, quality improvement team members, and others should plan to attend this year’s Quality & Safety Forum, scheduled for October 17-18 at the Radisson Paper Valley Hotel in Appleton.
Register today, and don’t forget to ask for the WHA Quality & Safety Forum room block at the Radisson Paper Valley Hotel when making your hotel reservation. Call 800-242-3499 to make your hotel reservation. The special room rate will be available only until September 18.
For more information, contact Sherry Rabuck or Jennifer Frank at 608-274-1820 or srabuck@wha.org or
jfrank@wha.org.Top
WHA Foundation Continues Technical College Scholarship Program for ’05-’06 School Year
The WHA Foundation, Inc. Board of Directors has agreed to continue the health care career scholarship program at technical colleges throughout Wisconsin for the 2005-2006 school year.
The scholarship program offers two scholarships to each of the state’s 16 technical colleges. The unique twist to the WHA Foundation scholarship program is that, unlike most scholarships, it covers actual tuition and book expenses, up to $2,000, for the final semester of a two-year, health care-related degree program. The intention is to assist and encourage students to make that one final push toward graduation and a career in health care.
Since the inception of the WHA Foundation scholarship program in 2003, scholarships have been granted to 58 students from all 16 technical colleges, worth approximately $69,000. For students who received the scholarships, they were able to complete their education and join the health care workforce, many at WHA member hospitals.
Of the 58 scholarship recipients, 41 were pursuing associate degrees in nursing. Others were pursuing degrees in radiography, health information technology, respiratory care, occupational therapy, sonography and physical therapy.
"The WHA Foundation is happy to play a part in supporting students training for health occupations and is pleased to enhance the many scholarship initiatives that our member hospitals and hospital volunteer organizations offer each year," said Jennifer Frank, executive director of the WHA Foundation.
The continuation of the scholarship program is in line with the WHA Foundation’s three funding priorities: (1) workforce development; (2) quality and patient safety; and (3) the Global Vision Community Partnership Award, which provides recognition and financial support to community health initiatives created in partnership with a WHA member. For more information on the WHA Foundation, contact Jennifer Frank at 608-274-1820 or
jfrank@wha.org.Top
2005 Annual Convention Focuses on Leading In an Era of Transparency
Brochure & registration form included in this week’s packet
Register today for the 2005 WHA Annual Convention, scheduled September 21-23 at the Kalahari Resort in Wisconsin Dells. Also, the final cut-off date for room reservations at the Kalahari Resort is Monday, August 29. Call 877-253-5466 to make your reservations today.
A strong line-up of presentations will bring the 2005 theme of "Health Care Leadership in an Era of Transparency" to life. This year’s convention begins with Dr. Jim Reinertsen, senior fellow for the Institute for Healthcare Improvement, president of The Reinertsen Group and former hospital CEO, discussing the changes and challenges of a successful health care leaders in this era of transparency. Thursday afternoon is devoted to the topic of community benefits, with an update from WHA’s Task Force on Community Benefits, a "lessons learned" presentation by an Illinois hospital fighting to regain its tax-exempt status, and a panel highlighting some of Wisconsin hospitals’ most innovative community benefit programs.
The full conference brochure, with registration information, is included in this week’s packet and is available online at www.wha.org. For more information on the program content, contact Jennifer Frank at 608-274-1820 or email jfrank@wha.org. For registration questions, contact Sherry Rabuck at 608-274-1820 or email
srabuck@wha.org.Top
Wisconsin Chapter of ACHE Offers Medical Staff Relations Program
The Wisconsin Chapter of ACHE is presenting a Category I (ACHE education) workshop entitled "Medical Staff Relations" on September 23, following the adjournment of the WHA Annual Meeting.
Few issues have greater impact on the success of a health care organization or an individual health care executive than that of medical staff relations. Understanding how to foster strong relationships between the medical staff and the organization can pay immeasurable benefits.
Panelists will share successful strategies for involving the medical staff in decision-making and planning and how to align the medical staff with organizational strategies. Attendees will learn some of the most effective communication vehicles to use with medical staff, what to do when medical staff competes with you, and how to deal with "oppositional factors" within the medical staff.
This program has been developed and is presented locally by the Wisconsin Chapter of ACHE. The American College of Healthcare Executives has awarded one (1) Category I (ACHE education) credit hour to this program.
The presenting panel will include John Rosing, MHA, FACHE, practice director of accreditation and regulatory services for the Greeley Company, who will act as moderator; Frank Byrne, MD, president of St. Marys Hospital Medical Center of Madison; James Casanova, MD, CPE, FACHE, senior vice president for medical affairs and chief medical officer for Aspirus Wausau Hospital of Wausau; and Michael Unger, MD, vice president of medical affairs for Community Memorial Hospital of Menomonee Falls.
The conference will be held at the conclusion of the WHA Annual Convention, on Friday, September 23, 2005, from 10:45 AM to 12:00 PM at the Kalahari Resort in Wisconsin Dells. There is no cost to register for this event, but pre-registration is requested. A brochure with registration form can be found on the web site at www.wha.org. Easy, on-line registration is available as well.
For more information on the program content, contact Gary Bezucha, FACHE, at 608-375-6204 or email gbezucha@boscobelhealth.com. For registration questions, contact Sherry Rabuck at 608-274-1820 or email at
srabuck@wha.org.Top
BQA Releases Memo Amending Authentication Variance
The Bureau of Quality Assurance amended its statewide variance concerning the authentication of physician orders effective August 22, 2005. In a recently released memo, BQA advised hospitals that the new statewide variance for HFS 124.12(5)(b)(11) concerning the authentication of physician orders is 48 hours rather than the previous variance of 72 hours. The new variance reads as follows:
"Medical staff by-laws and rules shall include . . . as statement specifying categories of personnel duly authorized to accept and implement medical staff orders. All orders shall be recorded and authenticated. All verbal and telephone orders shall be authenticated by the prescribing member of the medical staff in writing within 48 hours of receipt."
Under the federal Interpretive Guidelines for the Medicare Conditions of Participation, all oral or telephone orders for drugs and biologicals must be signed by the prescribing practitioner at the earliest of the following:
A copy of the BQA memo is available at http://dhfs.wisconsin.gov/rl_DSL/Publications/BQAnodMems.htm.
Stoughton Hospital Responds to Tornado DisasterFor the fourth time this year, Stoughton Hospital activated its Tornado warning procedure, but for the first time, it wasn’t a drill. On August 18, 2005, the ER staff was aware of the impending tornado because of the sirens, and then saw the funnel cloud from the north windows near the ER. They quickly implemented the Disaster Response protocol for the tornado that struck the north side of Stoughton moments earlier. Throughout the evening, the hospital was in constant contact with the Dane County Emergency Command Center as well as the American Red Cross. More than 80 professional, ancillary and volunteer staff reported to the hospital to aid victims and their families.
According to Jane McGuire, public relations and planning manager, "Stoughton Hospital, as well as the City of Stoughton Fire and EMS squads, had employees and volunteers, some whose own homes were affected by the disaster and yet they still responded in the field or to the hospital to help serve the greater community during its time of need. Their dedication and selflessness is an inspiration to us all."
The hospital released the following information regarding those who presented to the hospital: 20 were treated and released, two were admitted to Stoughton Hospital in fair condition, and 1 transferred via helicopter to a Madison hospital.
In the days following the tornado, Stoughton Hospital continued to provide care for disaster clean-up related injuries. Since the initial victims were treated, over 30 people have received care for disaster/clean-up related injuries. The majority of injuries were related to corneal abrasions, lacerations (some from chain saws), nail puncture wounds with related tetanus vaccination, and bee stings.
Hospital President Terry Brenny summed up the past few days, "The hospital would like to extend its appreciation to its staff as well as the emergency response teams throughout the Stoughton area who provided assistance. The hospital is also grateful for the outpouring of support it has received from the community."
Other area hospitals offered support: UW Hospital donated 1200 meals a day for the first two days after, along with donating supplies; and Meriter gave the American Red Cross supplies like bottled waters, fresh fruit and snacks.